States Parties shall respect and promote the right of the child
to participate fully in cultural and artistic life and shall encourage
the provision of appropriate and equal opportunities for cultural, artistic,
recreational, and leisure activity.
THE RIGHT TO PLAY
The adoption of this Article as the basis for a Play Policy ought not to be an idle gesture. The implications are quite far reaching. For example, "appropriate to the age of the child" is key and is not restricted to "No over-12's on this equipment" at play areas - what about their needs to play? In some areas, there is recognition that such young people also need outdoor play equipment, but equally that a toddler-sized slide does not fit the bill.
Or we can examine A31.2, and the commitment to "appropriate and equal opportunities" for children for cultural, artistic, recreational and leisure activity, and the onus is on the encouragement of provision, which may mean direct provision or working with and to encourage others to provide, but certainly is no mandate to do nothing.
There are other very crucial and relevant Articles in the Convention: A2: non-discrimination; A3: best interests of the child; A4: maximum use of resources; A12+13: the right to express opinion and to be heeded; A15: freedom of assembly and association; A18: provision of child-care; A19: prrotection from abuse; A23: rights of disabled children; A24: right to health; A27: standard of living; A28+29: right to and aims of education; A30: rights of minorities; A31: right to Play; A32/33/34/35: freedom from exploitation. All and an of these may have weight and relevance in a local area, and there is no case for the notion that the Convention affects only "foreign places". Britain has not been adjudged as anywhere near perfect by the international monitoring system put in place for the Convention.
[For those interested in the issues around Article 31, there is an Article 31 Network in which Fair Play is fully participating - details from Fair Play.]
THE CHARTER FOR CHILDREN'S PLAY
There is another standard for helping local authorities and others when formulating a Play Policy. The Charter for Children's Play was drawn up by the National Voluntary Council for Children's Play (now the Children's Play Council), based on Article 31, and is now being adopted by many local authorities and other agencies as the basis for their policies relating to Play. Membership of the Council is open to national voluntary bodies with an interest in Children's Play - there are now some 31 such bodies including Fair Play for Children (from which organisation the idea for a national Council stemmed). Local authorities adopting the Charter also are able to take part in the Council's work.
A FAIR DEAL FOR OUR CHILDREN
Article 31.2 makes implicit that adequate resources must be devoted to children's rest, recreation, leisure and play. "Appropriate and equal" is not confined to e.g. making sure that male and female children have equal opportunities, nor just between children with disabilities and those without, or between children of various ethnic groups etc. It must refer to the provision of appropriate and equal opportunities between CHILDREN AND ADULTS, children also being PEOPLE.
Therefore it is quite proper to be raising the extent to which children, in terms of Article 31.2, are able to access the resources and facilities provided by local authorities in terms of overall leisure and cultural spending in a local authority area. For example, the Audit Commission showed that in 1994/95, local authorities devoted £1.268 billion to public arts and recreation (excluding libraries), and in the same year £62.48 millions on children's play (including fixed area provision) or 4.9% of the total on arts and recreation.
(see Freedom to Play [Issue Paper 2] for further details)
CHILDREN - OUR POOR RELATIONS
It might be reasonably asked, what proportion of the population loccally do children form? If they form, as around the national average, 20%, then one might fairly argue, is 20% being spent on ensuring their appropriate and equal access to all cultural, artistic, recreational and leisure activity? At national level, when one considers that 20% of the population is under 16, and that on play Councils spend some 4.9% of their leisure and cultural budgets on Play, we are justified in asking whether another 15.1% of that £1.268 billions or more each year actually benefits children in terms of the "appropriate and equal" criterion of Article 31.2?
Fair Play doubts that this is so, and takes the view that, unless there is a proper examination of this equal opportunities aspect, a local Play Policy can be fatally compromised from the outset as it will fail to address a central issue, ever more relevant in an era of increasing competition for resources. If an authority's members, on having this challenge put to them, shake their heads sorrowfully and cluck sympathetically as if play workers will always automatically accept there are more pressing calls on resources, we need to be stating quite clearly the role of Play in ensuring the communities and environments in which children are growing up are fit for the task - the end result of failure to invest is, Fair Play argues, future loss of community, young people growing up knowing they have been cheated of childhood, and many problems which already confront communities today because of lack of foresight, fairness and investment in decades past.
APPROPRIATE AND EQUAL
Local authorities, in Fair Play's view, need to show that children are able to access fairly the resources devoted by local authorities to leisure - there may be ways to interest children in e.g.opera, but only a cynic would suggest it was possible or likely for most children to do so through the usual channels of access which are adult, expensive (and well-subsidised from the public purse), and quite simply, often inaccessible to many adults let alone children. We can debate whether opera, or any other activity, is "appropriate" and at what age, and there are queestion of access within activities which providers and funders need to address. But there is also the question, very relevant in terms of equal opportunities and limited resources, as to the balance between various activities.
For example, if a local authority places huge emphasis on prestige leisure centres strategically sited, then the question as to whether children, on a basis of accessibility through transport, cost etc, are being fairly served is a legitimate one.
- A. With the Main Dudes ....
- The aim of involvement in children's play, from an adult perspective, is their welfare. But what are the views, ideas, wishes, aims, objectives, hopes etc of the children themselves? The commitment to genuine, and on-going/ constant consultation should be as great as to all other services - "listening to the customer" is a oft-promoted objective across all areas of public service. The need to consult and listen to children about their play is important. It is no use neglecting Play for years between a Review, and once every few years indulging in some window-dressing, usually for the benefit of councillors rather than to ascertain children's views.
- B. The Voluntary Sector
- In formulating a Policy, a Local Authority would seem best advised to institute the widest-possible process of consultation taking in the voluntary sector (not only Play-based bodies but e.g. Councils for Voluntary Service, Rural Community Councils, special needs organisations, equal opportunities and community relations bodies etc), all Authority departments, other local and statutory bodies covering the area (e.g. health authorities), and any other relevant bodies.
- C. The Statutory Sector
- Consultation should be with other statutory sector bodies, such as County Councils, Parish Councils, Social Services, Health Authorities, Education Authorities, Housing Departments, Planning Authorities, Police, Youth Service and any one else who may have an interest in some or another aspect of Play.
- D. Others
- Such as local TECs, Further/Higher Education Colleges, other local networks (disability, out-of-school, under-8's, special education, parent, general voluntary sector, rural/community councils etc.
ELEMENTS OF A POLICY
It should cover:
- * the objectives and strategy underlying the Policy
- - what we want, why we want it, how we will get it and support it, how it relates e.g. to Article 31, leisure strategies etc
- * review of current provision and resources
- - what is happening, where, how, quality, resources, community involvement etc
- * what we want to provide/ why / how
- - fixed equipment provision
- - informal neighbourhood resources
- - organised activities (of all types)
- * support processes and resources
- - training and education (skills-based, NVQ-related, academic etc)
- - appropriate and equal opportunities
- - networking needs
- - child safety and protection
- - access
- - funding and resources
- * How are we doing?
- - feedback from children, parents and neighbourhoods
- - monitoring and evaluation
- - interagency liaison
QUALITATIVE AND QUANTITATIVE ASSESSMENT OF PROVISION
How does provision fit into the overall strategy of the local authorities as regards leisure, culture and recreation?
What needs are being met/ should be met?
What is the relationship with day care provision (as review by the relevant Social Services dept under Section 19 of the Children Act)?
Is current provision, in each category/type:
- adequate to the local community's needs?
- reflective of mobility and access within local communities?
- adequate in terms of children's play needs?
- helpful/supportive to parental interests?
- contributory to sound community development objectives?
- able to sustain the interest, involvement and support of children?
- reflective of differing needs: age groups, gender, ethnic/cultural, disability acceptance?
- consistent with all requirements of safety - e.g. child protection, accident prevention?
- reviewed regularly?
- adequate to the needs of children and of the communities in which they live?
- fully refelctive of the principle of Article 31.2 of the Convention, concerning "appropriate and equal opportunity" to access the local authority's cultural, recreational and leisure resources?
- directed to benefit children as a first priority (and not e.g. to justify maintaining or expanding establishments)?
- flexible as to their deployment to enable adjustment to changing circumstances?
- capable of expansion to redress existing imbalance?
- reviewed regularly?
Is Training Provision:
- adequately resourced?
- supportive of volunteers as well as employees?
- inclusive of management needs?
- sensitive to community and voluntary sector requirements?
- able to absorb the views of those seeking/ needing training?
- reviewed regularly?
POLICY FORMATION AND REVIEW
A Children's Play Policy will include:
* A Basic Statement of Aims to include incorporation of Article 31's basic objectives
* The Position of Children's Play within the local context, including the Local Authority's leisure, cultural and recreation strategy.
* Commitment to Article 31's "appropriate and equal opportunities" to ensure a "Fair Deal for Our Children"
- * Setting of Objectives and Targets for a defined Policy period:
- Types of Provision to be achieved
- Inter-agency working/liaison and detailed plan for implementation
- Resourcing levels
- The mix (authority/community/private)
- Training Provision and Development
- Consultation Procedures (children/ parents/ community/ others)
- Targets for new activities
- Safety including Child Protection
- Mointoring and Evaluation procedures
- Equal Opportunities - Development
FURTHER INFORMATION AND HELP:
Fair Play for Children: Campaigns for The Child's Right to Play. Information, advice, publications, Web site: [http://www.arunet.co.uk/fairplay/].
35 Lyon Street, Bognor Regis, West Sussex PO21 1BW, Tel/Fax: 01243-869922
Children's Play Council: Co-ordinates the work of 29 national voluntary agencies with an interest in play, formulated the Children's Play Charter, and is sseking adoption of this by local authorities and others. 8 Wakley Street London EC1V 7QE
National Playing Fields Association: has been awarded two-year contract to fulfil government objectives in the fields of national play information, playwork education and training, and playground safety. Tel: 0171-584 6445, 25 Ovington Square, London SW3 1LQ
ILAM Children's Panel, The Institute for Leisure Amenity Management, whose membership includes many working in local government leisure. 01491-874222, ILAM House, Lower Basildon, Reading Berks RG8 9NE.
[See also Fact Sheet 1, Useful Addresses, from Fair Play]